Tuesday, July 7, 2015

Ilana Blog Chapters 2 & 3

I thought this weeks chapters, “Chapter 2, The Impact of Social and Cultural Forces on the Academic Achievement of African American Males” and “Chapter 2, And What Will Become of Children Like Miguel Fernandez?/…Education, Immigration, and the Future of Latinos in the United States..”  were very interesting to read back to back. Noguera argues that both of these groups are in trouble, and explores challenges that they face. 

In chapter two, I was shocked to read the statistic that, “these is no greater evidence of long-term negative effects of living within an impoverished inner-city environment outweighed the damage inflicted by early exposure to drugs.”  Noguera explains that impoverished conditions greatly increase the multiplier effect on risk variables.  Variables that he listed are “single-parent household, low birth weight, low educational attainment of parents, and others.”  These are only some variables that are increased. 

This had me thinking about other variables that are affected by impoverished conditions.  I am an early childhood educator and a parent of a one and a half year-old girl, so conditions that affect early childhood development first came to mind.

For language development, talking to young children often is very much stressed in the world of Early Childhood Education.  Hearing and being exposed to language allows children to develop linguistically.  Early childhood teachers need to be aware of saying many words throughout the day.  When these teachers are assessed, there will often be a count of words that the teacher said throughout the say to ensure that they are exposing their students to enough language.  As a mother of a young child myself, I can attest that sometimes keeping a constant dialog with a little person at home who is not talking back can be hard.  My husband goes out of town during the week for work, so I am by myself all week.  Trying to balance my own work, taking care of our toddler, and keeping up the home can seem overwhelming!  I often have to remind myself to keep talking to my daughter.  There are times that I am tempted to plop her in front of the TV while I quickly get something done.  I will occasionally do this for a fifteen-minute interval even though I know it is not the best thing for her development.  When my husband is home, I find keeping dialog going easier to do because he will pitch in and play with our daughter or we have conversations together with our daughter. 

In my classroom and in my own home, I keep a very print rich environment, and suggest that my students’ parents do the same.  A print rich environment has many books and different print displayed prominently as well.  Families living in poverty do not have as much money for these books, magazines, alphabet charts and other resources that are available.  They also may not have the money for enrichment activities or have time to take their children to the library if they are working multiple jobs.

These are just some things that already make school more of a challenge for students living in impoverished homes right as they start school.  This makes it clear to me that as a teacher, it is so important to offer these developmental supports in the classroom.  Going above and beyond to use as much language as possible, providing high engagement books that represent all of the students, and keeping the environment as print rich as possible.  Do any of you have any other ideas that come to mind of challenges that these students face with early developmental support coming into school?

In chapter three, challenges of high school aged students working to get into college were what really stood out to me.  Working in the early childhood field, I am not aware of many the college acceptance requirements and challenges.  The example that really stood out to me was about Miguel, of whom the chapter is named after.  Miguel is an extremely hard worker and is spoke very highly of by all of his teachers.  Although he is an exemplary student, his hopes of getting into college are low he is an undocumented immigrant and he was not able to pass the English portion of the New York State Regents exam.  Although it seems that he would really strive in college and it would lead him to more opportunities, he plans to stay in the fast food industry.  These struggles are heartbreaking.  For those of you working with high school aged students, are there any struggles that you have personally seen any of your promising students face while trying to gain acceptance or enroll in college?  Do high schools offer extra support for English language learners in standardized testing?  Is there any help or support for these students to gain citizenship?


These chapters enlightened me on challenges students face from early childhood all the way through the end of high school and beyond.  As a teacher, it is so important to be aware of these challenges and things that we need to do to support all students.  I am interested in learning more ways to help. 

4 comments:

  1. First, Ilana, let me say that you are AWESOME! Having two pre-schoolers and teaching full-time and balancing a home myself is SUCH a hard thing. And my husband is rarely out of town on business, but when he does leave for a week, those weeks are inexplicably harder. Props to you for doing this EVERY WEEK!

    Then, as far as the question of high schoolers facing college entrance exams, etc., my kids are almost all white and in a small rural district. I think the problem most of them face are less of issues with language or acceptance into college, but more of the culture here. Many of their parents are farmers, and many of them have little to no formal post-high school education, yet are very successful. Most of my students then, even those who are very interested and could succeed very well in college, are almost "trapped" in their family culture. For instance, why pay or go into thousands upon thousands of dollars of debt simply to come back home to take over the family business which runs just fine without formal education? I know this culture issue is entirely different from anything we have read about so far, but it does get difficult when my kids don't really care about ACTs or what I can teach them because "they won't need it anyways". Additionally, I can only imagine if the cost of college is a deterrent to middle-class and upper-middle-class White families, how much more it is an issue for those minority students who are in a low socio-economic status. If my kids are saying, "Why do this? I don't need it anyways?" I believe the kids Noguera writes about probably have the same response, "Why do this? I won't be able to use it anyways." It's a sad state all around!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. :) Thanks Emily! It is super busy but so much fun! You’re kids are a little older than mine, is it true that you get to catch up on sleep eventually? Seems doubtful;)

      I do sometimes have a struggle with this thought on college as well. I obviously think college is extremely important institution and is really the way for most students to get ahead of the game. I am concerned with young students entering college without a true understanding of the debt that they are entering. Even since I was in undergrad around 10 years ago, interest rates have sky rocketed. My brother-in-law has graduated college with a communications degree over 3 years ago with a mountain of debt. He has been unsuccessful in finding a job that pays much more than minimum wage.

      I hope that this is an exception and not a rule for most students. I can, however, see if a student's reluctance to take loans and spend the time on a degree if they have a promising job awaiting them already. Clearly, going to college can help elevate them much higher in the long run- teaching them more about their trade. This is tricky and I really wish tuition/interest rates on loans weren't as devastating as they are! A little rant- but of all ways to tax or gain more money, why would the government choose to have young adults who are just making their way in life be bearers of such debt?

      Delete
  2. The piece on Miguel was also heartbreaking for me to hear. I was glad that he was going to still continue working and trying to achieve goals though. This is a sad reality that a lot of students face. I am in a middle school and I hear this being brought up already by students. They might not be taking an exam that they aren't able to pass the English portion of, but they find something that they have a deficiency in and they use that as an example as to why they won't be able to go to college and succeed. It truly is sad that at the middle school level they are already having a "realization" so to speak of their futures in terms of education. I think a lot of this has to deal with the borders that have been put up within the cultures of these students. They might be considered "sell outs" for acting a certain way and becoming better, or they might need to work to support their family as their dad will tell them that women can't work. These borders create big gaps in the students education and when they come to prepare for college they are left like Miguel in too many cases.
    We need to figure out how to change this as teachers. I don't think it will be easy by any means. I think we start by just getting to know our students cultures though and grow our relationships and bonds from there.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, our relationships and bonds with our students can do so much to help them individually and help us learn to reform curriculum!

      Delete